Order of Man
Host Ryan Michler comes in as an open skeptic who neither drinks nor uses drugs, asking how, if at all, this could make a man better. Matt meets the skepticism head on, framing psychedelics as a technology reached through three doors, medical, decriminalization, and religious.
LISTEN
Apple Podcasts ↗ Watch on YouTube ↗
Episode summary
On Order of Man, host Ryan Michler comes to the subject as an open skeptic, a man who does not drink or use drugs and who keeps asking how, if at all, this could make someone a better man. Matt meets the skepticism directly. He describes psychedelics as a technology as much as a medicine, a tool people reach through one of three doors, medical, decriminalization, or religious. He tells the story of the guided psilocybin session that reconnected him with his late mother and reordered his life, and mentions a side effect he did not expect, that his desire to drink fell away entirely and never came back.
Michler presses on the hard questions. Is a spiritual experience anything more than new connections firing in the brain? Matt grants that no one fully knows, but points to staying power, the way people still name these experiences as turning points years later. When the host challenges the idea of switching off shame, blame, and guilt, arguing those emotions can serve a person, Matt clarifies that the effect is specific and temporary, tied to one memory a person is working through. He illustrates with his own account, which he writes about in his book, of revisiting inappropriate sexual contact he survived as a young teen with an older family member, and finally setting down something he had carried for decades.
Much of the hour is a careful back-and-forth on the evidence. Matt walks through how PTSD is measured and what treatment resistant means, and cites the MDMA trial results for people the existing options had failed. He and Michler trade thoughts on how the prohibition took hold, drawing a parallel to other suppressed plants, and Matt points to the harm ranking from David Nutt that places alcohol well above mushrooms and most other psychedelics. He is careful with language, preferring risk reduction to any claim of safety, and is blunt that the title Psychedelics for Everyone is an argument for understanding these medicines well rather than a suggestion that everyone should take one.
They get practical toward the end. Matt explains what ketamine is, the only legal option, and runs through its short and long term side effects honestly, including the bladder issues seen with heavy recreational use. He covers the counterintuitive use of psychedelics for addiction, from the AA founder's interest in LSD to ibogaine for opioid dependence, and notes that most classic psychedelics are not themselves addictive. He describes his own ceremonial practice as occasional rather than routine, shares a recent session in which he reconnected with his late father, and stresses that whatever a person tries, the questions to ask about source, preparation, and integration are the same. He points readers to his book and to Michael Pollan's work as starting points.